EDUCATION / ARTICLE
H2 Economics Externalities: Find the Units That Create Deadweight Loss
TestPapersFree · 2026-11-19 08:04:08
An incoming JC student on SGExams asked what H2 Economics involves, and the discussion turned to how students reason from diagrams. An externality diagram is a good example. Once you’ve labelled the curves, the next job is to identify which units the market misallocates and explain what society loses on those units. SGExams discussion about H2 Economics and graph analysis.
SEAB’s 2026 H2 Economics syllabus, 9570, covers externalities, deadweight loss and the socially efficient quantity where marginal social benefit equals marginal social cost. Its guidance uses the gap between social and private costs for negative externalities and the gap between social and private benefits for positive externalities. The two practice markets below use hypothetical numbers so you can check each intersection as you draw. SEAB’s 2026 H2 Economics syllabus, Theme 2.3.
Negative externality means checking the extra units
Imagine a competitive market for an item whose production creates noise for residents near a workshop. Buyers receive the private benefit. Producers bear labour and materials costs. In this simplified model each extra unit also creates $6 of noise cost for residents, and there is no external benefit. On a diagram with quantity on the horizontal axis and dollars per unit on the vertical axis, draw marginal private benefit (MPB) equal to marginal social benefit (MSB), both given by 20 − Q. Draw marginal private cost (MPC) as 2 + Q and marginal social cost (MSC) as 8 + Q.
The market equates MPB and MPC at Q = 9. Society’s efficient output equates MSB and MSC at Q = 6. Mark both quantities before shading. For quantities above 6 through 9, MSC exceeds MSB. The market produces those units because the buyer’s marginal benefit still covers the producer’s marginal private cost over that interval, including equality at the market endpoint. Producing those units creates more total cost than benefit for society.
Shade between MSC and MSB from Q = 6 to Q = 9. The gap at Q = 6 is zero, and at Q = 9 it is $6 per unit. With these straight lines, the triangle has area ½ × 3 × $6 = $9. A gap between MSC and MPC shows the external cost per unit. The welfare calculation uses the gap between MSC and MSB over the units produced in excess of the efficient quantity.
Positive externality means checking the missing units
In a separate hypothetical market, imagine paid sessions that teach participants how to repair shared bicycles. Suppose each session gives other users a $4 marginal benefit from better-maintained bicycles, while marginal private and social costs are the same. Keep MPB at 20 − Q and MPC at 2 + Q. Set MSB to 24 − Q and MSC equal to MPC. The market quantity is still 9, and the social optimum is now 11.
Between 9 and 11 the private benefit falls short of the private cost, so the market leaves those units unprovided. The social benefit exceeds the social cost until the curves meet at 11. Shade between MSB and MSC over that interval. The gap falls from $4 to zero, so the area is ½ × 2 × $4 = $4. Here the lost welfare is the net benefit society could have gained from providing the missing units.
Make your paragraph follow the diagram
When you try a prelim question, label the third party, name the two equilibrium conditions and bracket the interval between the quantities. Then write a sentence comparing social benefit with social cost on that interval. If you wrote ‘there is deadweight loss because there is an externality’, use your diagram to add which units are produced or forgone and why they reduce net social benefit. Practise explaining this in words even when the paper supplies no numerical curves. TestPapersFree H2 Economics collection.
Add Comment
This policy contains information about your privacy. By posting, you are declaring that you understand this policy:
This policy is subject to change at any time and without notice.
These terms and conditions contain rules about posting comments. By submitting a comment, you agree with these rules:
Failure to comply with these rules may result in being banned from submitting further comments.
These terms and conditions are subject to change at any time and without notice.
Comments